Key Takeaways
- Shanghai High Court acknowledges the "property attributes" of cryptocurrencies under Chinese law, permitting their use as commodities.
- While providing property protections, the court condemns crypto-related fundraising as illegal public financing.
- Despite China's support for blockchain in cross-border payments, it maintains a strict stance against widespread cryptocurrency adoption.
Court Ruling Details
The Shanghai High People's Court recently ruled that crypto assets possess "property attributes" and aren't entirely prohibited under Chinese law. However, these protections only apply to cryptocurrencies used as commodities—not as currencies or commercial instruments.
These remarks were made during a fraud case involving two companies and a failed token offering, with the court delivering strong condemnation of their actions.
China's Strict Crypto Policies
The ruling addresses a dispute between an unnamed agricultural development company and an investment management firm regarding a virtual currency issuance agreement.
Supreme Court statement:
"Raising funds through illegal token issuance and circulation—collecting so-called 'virtual currencies' like Bitcoin and Ethereum from investors—constitutes unauthorized illegal public financing. Therefore, no organization or individual may engage in illegal token issuance or financing activities."
Despite this harsh stance, the court clarified that cryptocurrencies aren't without legitimate applications. It recognized their commodity value and noted no blanket prohibition exists on their use.
Shifting Perspectives?
Since China halted Bitcoin mining in 2021, international observers have closely watched for signs of cryptocurrency reintegration into the world's second-largest economy. Recent developments include:
- Hong Kong approving its first Bitcoin ETF earlier this year, giving mainland investors indirect exposure.
- BRICS nations endorsing blockchain technology for cross-border payments, with Russia taking a more optimistic view than China on crypto adoption.
- China's digital yuan (CBDC) being actively used in international trade.
Meanwhile, global figures have weighed in:
- Former U.S. President Donald Trump proposed using Bitcoin to counter Chinese economic influence.
- Tron founder Justin Sun urged China to embrace blockchain technology, warning that restrictive policies could cede technological advantages to other nations.
Persistent Regulatory Caution
Despite these developments, China's fundamental crypto stance shows little sign of softening. While the high court acknowledged potential legitimate uses, it handled the current case severely:
- The investment manager allegedly defrauded partners to fund a token offering.
- The court framed this as emblematic of crypto's inherent risks.
- Large-scale commercial transactions using cryptocurrencies—especially new token issuances—remain strictly prohibited.
The judgment reiterated concerns that Bitcoin could destabilize financial systems and facilitate illegal activities, reflecting China's entrenched anti-crypto position in official policy.
FAQ Section
Q: Does this ruling make cryptocurrencies legal in China?
A: No. The court only recognized cryptocurrencies' "property attributes" for commodity use—not as currencies or financial instruments. Most crypto activities remain banned.
Q: Can Chinese citizens legally trade Bitcoin now?
A: No. While the ruling provides limited property protections, trading cryptocurrencies as assets or using them for payments remains prohibited.
Q: How does this affect blockchain development in China?
A: China continues supporting blockchain technology (especially for enterprise/cross-border applications) while maintaining strict controls on cryptocurrency speculation and public offerings.
Q: What was the court's main criticism in this case?
A: It condemned the token offering as "illegal public financing," emphasizing that unauthorized fundraising via crypto violates financial regulations.
Q: Could China's stance on crypto change in the future?
A: While incremental adjustments are possible (like Hong Kong's ETF approval), systemic policy shifts appear unlikely given current financial stability priorities.
👉 Explore secure crypto trading platforms for compliant digital asset management.
👉 Learn about blockchain's role in global finance and how institutions are adapting.